SciScoop Science News header image

Use It Or Lose It…

CognitiveScience Sunday, August 22, 2004 . This is a SciScoop post by janra

  • Share/Bookmark

Peter Gordon of Columbia University studied the Pirahã and found that they had great difficulty when asked to work with numerous objects. The Pirahã are by no means retarded, however: they have excellent capabilities in other areas such as spatial orientation and linguistics, and clearly understood the task they were asked to do. In this case, the lack of specific words for numbers higher than two made it difficult for them to think about numbers higher than two or three. Even after some of the adults requested math lessons they still couldn’t learn even the most basic mathematical concepts.

Whether or not – and to what extent – our language affects how we think has been debated for over a century. This new research adds another piece of evidence to that argument, as well as to the idea that concepts for which we have no words are harder to think about. This has been seen in other places as well: the Zuni indians, for example, use the same word for orange as for yellow. While they can see the difference between the two colours, they are less likely to remember if a particular object was orange or yellow after a period of time than an English speaker, who codifies the difference between the two colours in the language, does.

5 Responses to Use It Or Lose It…

kryptothesuperdog

August 23rd, 2004 at 4:42 am

Just to say that I recently read Steven Pinker’s How The Mind Works which goes into detail on the relation of language and thought. I found the book absolutely fascinating (second only to The Blind Watchmaker in terms of exclaim-out-loud information) and would thoroughly recommend it to anyone interested in the mind, especially if, like me, you have little existing knowledge of cognitive science.

Avatar

BigZaphod

August 23rd, 2004 at 10:19 am

This is entirely off topic..  but wow..  I swear we follow each other around the web janra..  :-)  I see you everywhere I go from K5 and now here.  It’s a small web, apparently…

Avatar

Anonymous

August 23rd, 2004 at 3:40 pm

I read this site occasionally through RSS, and nearly didn’t pick this one up due to a crappy title. A better title would be “Language: Use it or Lose it”

Avatar

Anonymous

August 24th, 2004 at 8:48 am

Perhaps their language doesn’t accomodate higher numbers because they have always had a genetic predisposition to not being able to remember higher numbers? Maybe their language reflects their latent (dis)abilities rather than causes them.

Avatar

Sweetwind

August 24th, 2004 at 8:55 am

I have added a reminder to that effect to the submission guidelines that appear when submitting a story.

Avatar

Comment Form

About

SciScoop Science News is a forum for news, views and controversial conjectures. please contact us to submit a guest blog post idea to become an author.

SciScoop Top Authors