Anthropology Tuesday, February 21, 2006 . This is a SciScoop post by worldscience
An editor of a noted scientific journal says he has discovered a genetic defect that seems to set back the clock on human evolution by more than a million years.
Its victims walk on all fours and mouth a primitive language, the scientist reported. He added that the syndrome may literally undo eons of human evolution, and thus reflect with some accuracy what our ape-like ancestors were like.
The researcher, Uner Tan of Cukurova University Medical School in Adana, Turkey, has posted an online video clip of an affected woman walking on all fours, her face blurred.
The idea that evolution can run backward isn’t new; some scientists say there have been confirmed cases of it in animals. But it’s also a controversial subject, and considered hard to prove in any given case.
Tan, at any rate, argued that this could be a case of it, so the mutation–known to run in one Turkish family–might offer scientists an unprecedented glimpse into human origins.
…
The paper appears in the March issue of the International Journal of
Neuroscience, where Tan sits on the editorial board. He also named the disorder after himself: Unertan syndrome.
Previously: « New: The Apple Light
SciScoop Science News is a forum for news and views. Please contact us if you would like to submit a guest post. NO link-bait spam, thanks. Commenting is time-limited to the most recent posts, please keep comments on-topic, timely and spam-free.
3 Responses to "Backward Evolution" Spawns Ape-like People
barakn
February 25th, 2006 at 4:55 pm
That’s odd, because they look like anatomically-modern humans awkwardly walking around on all fours. They walk on their palms rather than their knuckles like chimpanzees, gorillas, and the earliest human ancestors, and the arm-to-leg length ratio is completely wrong for quadrupedalism. The transition to bipedalism affected almost every bone in the skeleton and involved mutations in many genes. The idea that this could be undone by a single mutation is patently absurd. What happens if advocates of eugenics get ahold of this story? They might argue that the victims of this disorder are at least a million years behind the human race and are therefore not really human. it would not be much of a stretch for a neo-Nazi to switch from thinking of these people as “ape-like” to simply “apes” which can be killed to purify the human race.
Finally, I’d like to point out that the International Journal of Neuroscience has had problems with not fully refereeing papers submitted by members of its own editorial board. For example, check the controversy surrounding the creationist Dmitri Kuznetsov and his paper which, amongst other things, referred to papers or journals which did not exist.
telescopeguy
March 3rd, 2006 at 10:15 am
Linguists are also guilty of such overreaction to discoveries of perhaps marginal import- Specific Language Impairment comes to mind as the ‘major discovery’ of the previous decade. One finds that the discoverer’s own understanding of human evolution, on the one hand, and evolutionary theory, on the other, tends to be rather primitive itself.
Overreaching beyond one’s area of expertise is nothing new- how many of us remember physical chemist Linus Pauling’s foray into vitamin C?
As the man said, a cobbler should stick to his last…
In any case it is obvious that to see reverse human evolution in action one has to look no further than the hallowed halls of Washington, D.C.
telescopeguy
March 3rd, 2006 at 11:47 am
Speaking of cobbler’s lasts, my granddad’s old last (he wasn’t actually a cobbler, but fixed his family’s shoes) finds great utility in holding open our summerhouse door in the summer.
But, yes, point taken on the posting…
Sometimes even scientists talk “cobblers” (Look it up in a cockney rhyming slang dictionary)
db