SciScoop Science News header image

Carrot Tops Healthy Veg

science Wednesday, June 17, 2009 . This is a SciScoop post by David Bradley

  • Share/Bookmark

News from my Newcastle University published today reveals that cooking carrots whole and then chopping them before serving is better for your health than slicing and dicing before you boil.

Apparently, less of the “anticancer” compound falcarinol leaches out of the carrots and into the cooking water if carrots are boiled whole. Of course, the truly health conscious will be steaming their vegetables rather than direct boiling. Chopped carrots cooked retain 25 percent less falcarinol than those cooked whole, according to Newcastle’s Kirsten Brandt, Ahlam Rashed, and their colleagues.

Whether or not roasting, grilling or cooking in carrot cake could form part of a future study Brandt revealed today.

She also points out that the natural sugars in carrots that give the orange root vegetable its distinctive sweet flavor are also found in higher concentrations in whole-cooked carrot. Their study also addressed this issue with a taste panel and seemingly whole-cooked carrots are tastier.

Brandt and colleagues first discovered the health benefits of falcarinol in carrots four years ago in collaboration with her colleagues at the University of Southern Denmark. The initial tests were on raw carrots but Brandt points out that cooking softens cell walls that allow easier ingestion of beneficial compounds.

“We all want to try to improve our health and diet by getting the right nutrients and eating our five-a-day fresh fruit and vegetables,” says Brandt, “The great thing about this is it’s a simple way for people to increase their uptake of a compound we know is good for you, all you need is a bigger saucepan.”

Original research on falcarinol from 2005:

Research Blogging IconChristensen, L., Vach, W., Ritskes-Hoitinga, J., & Brandt, K. (2005). Inhibitory Effects of Feeding with Carrots or (-)-Falcarinol on Development of Azoxymethane-Induced Preneoplastic Lesions in the Rat Colon Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 53 (5), 1823-1827 DOI: 10.1021/jf048519s

5 Responses to Carrot Tops Healthy Veg

Rachel

June 17th, 2009 at 11:30 pm

Does this matter if making soup/stew? wouldn’t the nutrientsjust remain in the broth or does being in the water denature them somehow?

Avatar

Mike

June 18th, 2009 at 3:03 am

Hey, nice post, really well written. You should blog more about this.

Avatar

David Bradley

June 18th, 2009 at 8:34 am

The study is purely about cooking carrots and then draining them, so you’re right, if you’re a broth or stew person I think you’re okay. Some vitamins and phytochemicals are heat sensitive though and degrade. To be honest, all the health claims about different components in fruit and vegetables and their potential benefits are overblown. Eating a balanced diet is certainly better than not eating a balanced diet but whether or not having carrots boiled whole or sliced is really not going to make any serious difference to your lifetime risk of cancer regardless of the levels of falcarinol or any other compound.

Avatar

David Bradley

June 18th, 2009 at 8:41 am

Loved your response Mike, I think that makes it the 20th time you’ve said the exact same thing on SciScoop.com. To be honest, there’s little point in my blogging more about this subject I’ve said all that needs to be said, moreover, I don’t think it was particularly well written, it was just a quick blog post done in less than half an hour, not a 69-chapter thesis on the state of human health.

I really do hope you’re on your way to making $1000 a day with your scheme. However, as you may have noticed I haven’t approved your comments nor your links. You have to admit you were simply after free advertising.

By the way, we have a policy to spam filter affiliate marketers, pyramid sales reps etc, as my readers really don’t need to see endless ads of that nature.

Avatar

EdwardT

June 29th, 2009 at 3:26 pm

I look forward to the ambitious followup research involving microwaves.

Avatar

Comment Form

About

SciScoop Science News is a forum for news, views and controversial conjectures. Please contact us if would like to submit a guest post.

SciScoop Top Authors